| Issue | Cover Appearance? | Comment | Reprinted In |
| All-American #25 | No | (no title) - Origin and 1st Appearance, I:Myra Mason, Hooty, vs "Killer" Maroni | Justice League of America #95 |
| All-American #26 | No | (no title) - vs. River Pirate Gang, exposes crooked politician Merton Marlow | |
| All-American #27 | No | (no title) - captures "Gallows" Gallagher | |
| All-American #28 | No | (no title) - vs. gangsters, hijacking a plane full of gold | |
| All-American #29 | No | (no title) - prevents group, the Cobras, from framing and lynching a labor leader | |
| All-American #30 | No | (no title) - foils crooks sabotaging a mine | |
| All-American #31 | No | (no title) - breaks up gang fleecing people witha phony seance | |
| All-American #32 | No | (no title) - breaks up spy-ring | |
| All-American #33 | No | (no title) - vs. the Napola gang trying to steal a Chinese urn for Sun Sen | |
| All-American #34 | No | (no title) - exposes a crooked physician | |
| All-American #35 | No | (no title) - captures crooks extorting a mayoral candidate | |
| All-American #36 | No | (no title) - a murderer bamboozles the sister of a fellow parolee by switching places with her brother | |
| All-American #37 | No | (no title) - defeats foreign agents striking at the American Defense Effort | |
| All-American #38 | No | (no title) - breaks up a quack's phoney medicine racket | |
| All-American #39 | No | (no title) - captures Steve Fink, a gangster threatening a movie crew over a film ridiculing gangsters | |
| All-American #40 | No | (no title), captures Nazi agents | |
| All-American #41 | No | (no title), capture traitors and Japanese agents | |
| All-American #42 | No | (no title), captures Nazi agents | |
| All-American #43 | No | (no title), stop saboteurs at an American defense factory | |
| All-American #44 | No | "The Night has 1,000 Eyes" - stops crooks from killing police informant | |
| All-American #45 | No | (no title) - rescues miners caught in cave-in and apprehends man behind the disaster | |
| All-American #46 | No | "The Half-Pint Policeman" - son avengers father's death at the hands of "Monk" Naddo | |
| All-American #47 | No | (no title) - exposes phoney caveman trying to frighten away tourists | |
| All-American #48 | No | "The Mystery of Gamwell's Home for the Blind" - captures counterfieters at home for the blind | |
| All-American #49 | No | "The Clock Strikes Twelve", a suitor of Myra Mason's gets involved with crime and is bailed out by Dr. Mid-Nite | |
| All-American #50 | No | "The Beggar King" - vs "Hobble", a kid who was turned to crime by an abusive father, but cured by Dr Mid-Nite | |
| All-American #51 | No | "The City of Silent Night" - In a visit to Keystone City, captures a criminal using a silencing device during crimes | |
| All-American #52 | No | "The Aging Death" - captures crooks using a metabolizer device to speed up aging | |
| All-American #53 | No | "Caught by Coincidence" - captures Dwight, a submarine saboteur | |
| All-American #54 | No | "The Man Who Defeated Death" - Dr. Mid-Nite is shrunk to miniature size to kill germs in a man's body | |
| All-American #55 | No | "The Riddle of the Blazing Dummy" - captures "Three Fingers" Domigan | |
| All-American #56 | No | "The Tale of the Black Rain" -vs. The Cloud, a criminal who has learned a way to make the sky rain black ink to cover his crimes | |
| All-American #57 | No | "The Man Who Bought Shadows" - vs Shade, a crook using a scheme swindle people after "buying" their shadow | |
| All-American #58 | No | "Limmericks vs Larceny" - criminals kidnap writer to win rhyme contest | |
| All-American #59 | No | "Banana Peels and Crooked Heels" - crook sets up fruit stand near jewelry store, robs it and hides jewels in fruit | |
| All-American #60 | No | "The Man Who Spoke in Whispers", Crooks terrorize a bank teller | |
| All-American #61 | No | "The Man with Two Lives", helps criminal Barton reform via "memory surgery" | |
| All-American #62 | No | "The Man Who Feared Guns", helps policeman afraid of firearms | |
| All-American #63 | No | (no title), helps reform the McCartney brothers and the youngest of which to become an honest physician | |
| All-American #64 | No | "The Color of Crime", clears an aging color-blind of murder | |
| All-American #65 | No | "The Curse of the Baleful Banshee", vs. The Baleful Banshee, a criminal ministrel | |
| All-American #66 | No | "The Walking Bomb", vs. Mr. Nitro, a criminal who drinks nitroglycerin and threatens to explode if anyone opposes him | |
| All-American #67 | No | "Excursion to Excitement", riverboat trip changes lives of gangster, businessmen | |
| All-American #68 | No | "The Curse of the Caliphs", exposes phoney rajah | |
| All-American #69 | No | "The Fisherman's Folly", Kurt Hartmann, an angling crook | |
| All-American #70 | No | "Poor Pablo", On vacation in Mexico, Dr. Mid-Nite helps a famous bandit's son avoid a life of crime | |
| All-American #71 | No | "Words of Wisdom", helps former youth gang member settle up with former pals | |
| All-American #72 | No | "Drama in the Dark", vs. Cannon Cane and Torpedo Tolin | |
| All-American #73 | No | "The Valley of the City Of Gold", investigates mystery of city that all who see it die | |
| All-American #74 | No | "The House Where Things Went Wrong", captures nephew spooking elderly aunt and uncle to rob them | |
| All-American #75 | No | "Gamblers of the Gridiron", captures Slim & Henchmen | |
| All-American #76 | No | "The Man with Long Distance Eyes" | |
| All-American #77 | No | "The Cardboard Hero", helps Eddie Vickers | |
| All-American #78 | No | "Holiday from Healing", helps Fred Vincent, a hypochondriac | |
| All-American #79 | No | "Cracked Ice", vs Ice Ingram, the diamond theif | |
| All-American #80 | No | "Pay Dirt", helps out farmer bamboozles by crooks about gold mine | |
| All-American #81 | No | "Say It With Flowers", Solves crime of man trying to frame a neice to improve his lot in the uncle's will | |
| All-American #82 | No | "Dr. Mid-Nite and Dr. Light", I: Dr. Light, vs Dr. Light | |
| All-American #83 | No | "Bad Blood Between Brothers", resolves the Morton brothers' family feud | |
| All-American #84 | No | "The Tunnel That Couldn't Be Finished" - vs. crooks sabotaging tunnels | |
| All-American #85 | No | "Accidents on Order", movie studio sabotage | |
| All-American #86 | No | "Cue for Death", vs. Lewis, murders actors | |
| All-American #87 | No | "How Dr. Mid-Nite Captured Big-Shot Barnes", gangster Big-Shot Barnes tries to killed McNider for writing about him. | |
| All-American #88 | No | "The Tarantula unmasks Dr. Mid-Nite", vs. The Tarantula | DC 100-Page Spectacular #20 |
| All-American #89 | No | "Out of this World", vs. Dr. Light | |
| All-American #90 | No | (no title), a "Twilight Zone" type tale in which a ghost (?) gets Dr. Mid-Nite to solve his murder | |
| All-American #91 | No | "The Crime Flowers", vs. Dr. Light | |
| All-American #92 | No | "Seconds to Live", McNider poisoned but thwarts criminals anyway. | |
| All-American #93 | No | "The Village That Time Forgot", a mystic mist takes Dr. Mid-Nite back in time to defeat the Black Baronet and save Avonshire | |
| All-American #94 | No | "Murder by Accident", thwarts rodeo takeover | |
| All-American #95 | No | "How Dr. Mid-Nite defeated Boss King", vs. Boss King | |
| All-American #96 | No | "The Unsinkable Bandits", vs crooks in a submersible automobile | |
| All-American #97 | No | "The Doctor Takes A Walk", defeats various gangsters in time to meet a publication deadline | |
| All-American #98 | No | "The Strange Case of the Sky-Raider", vs. Sky Raider, a felon in a eskimo parka driving a flying dog sled | |
| All-American #99 | No | "The Laughing Crooks" - foils a gang of gimmicky crooks from robbing a night club | |
| All-American #100 | No | "The Man Who Lived in a Boot", vs crooks operating out of a Veags style hotel shaped like a boot | |
| All-American #101 | No | "The Case of the Talking Shadows" | Detective #445 |
| All-American #102 | No | "The Saboteurs of Science", vs. Revelk and gang |