| Issue | Cover Appearance? | Comment | Reprinted In |
| Big All-American Comic #1 | Yes | "Models for Crime" - rescues toy maker from crooks | |
| Sensation #1 | No | (no title) -1st Appearance, I: Wanda Wilson, vs. Big Shot | Famous First Editions #3, Sensation Comics #1 Millenium Edition |
| Sensation #2 | No | (no title) - saves boy's home from foreclosure | |
| Sensation #3 | No | (no title) - uncovers political fraud in Santa Flora | |
| Sensation #4 | No | (no title) - helps a school chum break up the protection racket of Dapper Joe and company | |
| Sensation #5 | No | (no title) - breaks up gambling ring | |
| Sensation #6 | No | (no title) - breaks up a confidence racket | |
| Sensation #7 | No | (no title) - foils graft in a public food program | |
| Sensation #8 | No | (no title)- vs. a crooked carnival | |
| Sensation #9 | No | (no title) - captures "Ferret" McGee, a crooked detective | |
| Sensation #10 | No | (no title) - thwarts crooks at Indianapolis raceway | |
| Sensation #11 | No | (no title) - vs. Nazis in Maine | |
| Sensation #12 | No | (no title) - vs. Mr. Laff, a crook basing crimes on practical jokes | |
| Sensation #13 | No | (no title) - vs. Terry Savatte, a crooked former tap dancer | |
| Sensation #14 | No | "Framed" - clears Wanda Wilson of murder | |
| Sensation #15 | No | "Mr. Terrific Took A Vacation" | |
| Sensation #16 | No | "The Case of the Unhappy Dog" - rescues a kid from a cruel guardian after the dog puts him wise | |
| Sensation #17 | No | "The Emperor's Millions" - thwarts a shyster seeking to bilk an emperor's heir | |
| Sensation #18 | No | "The Case of the Radio Robbers"- Cons try to get Mr. Terrific to record bond ads so they can commit robberies while he is on the radio | |
| Sensation #19 | No | "I Quit" - breaks up a stock fraud racket | |
| Sensation #20 | No | "The Masqueraders" - Terry Sloane impersonated | |
| Sensation #21 | No | "The Case of the Bogus Baron" | |
| Sensation #22 | No | (no title) - vs. crooks involve in boxing | |
| Sensation #23 | No | (no title) - vs. crooks who try to subvert an old man's efforts to honor his fallen son | |
| Sensation #24 | No | "A Symphony of Sock" - vs. crooks targeting a concert pianist | |
| Sensation #25 | No | "Seeing is not Believing" - crooks invite victims to gambling den and then rob then until Mr. Terrific tracks them down | |
| Sensation #26 | No | "The Puzzling Portraits" - vs phony art collectors trying to scam art gallery | |
| Sensation #27 | No | "Shadow on the Wall" - clears the name of Jim Cowley, a convict framed for murder | |
| Sensation #28 | No | "The Fate of the Future" - vs. Black Barax, a would be dictator from the year 7532 A.D. | |
| Sensation #29 | No | "The Man Who Could Make Diamonds" - rescues a scientist with a diamond making machine from criminals | |
| Sensation #30 | No | "The Case of the Cat's Meow" - captures jewel thieves | |
| Sensation #31 | No | "The Blindfold Test" - captures Nails Jackson, who tries to defeat the Mr. Terrific when the hero is blindfolded. | |
| Sensation #32 | No | "The Secret of the Stolen Statue" - solves the murder of sculptor Grace Naylin | |
| Sensation #33 | No | "The Magician Meets His Master" - captures crooked Swami | |
| Sensation #34 | No | "Air Tight Alibi" - captures racketeer "King" Krug | |
| Sensation #35 | No | "The Man Who Outsmarted Himself" - thwarts jewel thief who has stashed loot on a sunken boat | |
| Sensation #36 | No | "The Builder of Crime" | |
| Sensation #37 | No | "Lightning Strikes Twice!" rescues scientist Dr. Wilkin from his greedy nephew | |
| Sensation #38 | No | ||
| Sensation #39 | No | "The Boarder Who Forgot!" - develops amnesia but recovers to thwart criminal who fakes his own murder | |
| Sensation #40 | No | "The Monster of Mudville" - fights a timid druggist turned into a giant by contaminated water. | |
| Sensation #41 | No | (no title) - vs gangsters | |
| Sensation #42 | No | "Crime Goes to School!" - breaks up a reform school that teaches delinquents to be real criminals. | |
| Sensation #43 | No | "The Crimes that Couldn't Work!" - a crime story writer acts out his crimes to prove they work | |
| Sensation #44 | No | "Crime on the Downbeat"- thwarts crooks who play a phonograph as a distraction while they commit crimes | |
| Sensation #45 | No | "The Violent Violin" - thwarts theft of Maestro Allegro's violin | |
| Sensation #46 | No | "Futile's Follies" - vs. Mr. Futile | |
| Sensation #47 | No | "Wanda Wilson's Mistake" - Theft of Wanda's jewel box | |
| Sensation #48 | No | "Losses Pay A Profit" - breaks up a swindling racket | |
| Sensation #49 | No | "Tale of the Tattooed Eye!" - vs. Don Grieco the Hypnotist | |
| Sensation #50 | No | "Mr. Terrific Goes to the Dogs" - rescues crippled girl with help from her dog | |
| Sensation #51 | No | "Five Geniuses in Search of a Hobby!" - 5 talented guys get bored and begin to commit crimes to entertain themselves | |
| Sensation #52 | No | "The Missing Composers" - capture kidnapped composers | |
| Sensation #53 | No | "The Man With the Gun" - Hoods pin gun on former jurist | |
| Sensation #54 | No | "The Face of Shen San" - foils thefts by son of former archeologists trying to reconstruct an ancient jade necklace | |
| Sensation #55 | No | (no title) - breaks up crooks infiltrating detective school | |
| Sensation #56 | No | "The Boy Who Had No Friends" - helps neglected son avoid a life of crime | |
| Sensation #57 | No | "The Wonderful Algy" - vs crooks pursuing author | |
| Sensation #58 | No | "The Book of Alibis" | |
| Sensation #59 | No | "The Most Honest Man In Town" - Reforms Pop Crock and Slash Gates | |
| Sensation #60 | No | "The Good Deed" - foils jewels thieves posing as philanthropists | |
| Sensation #61 | No | "Give 'Em The Bird" - A vaudeville trained penguin helps Mr. Terrific captures crooks | |
| Sensation #62 | No | "The Man Who Remembered Too Much" - vs. Dr. I.M. Smart, scammer | |
| Sensation #63 | No | "A Juror Disappears" - busts a gangster for jury tampering |